Top 10 Hidden Speakeasies in New York

Dear Irving Gramercy transports guests through different eras with each uniquely designed room, from Victorian parlor to 1920s salon to mid-century modern lounge. The seasonal cocktail menu changes regularly, but the house Negroni variations are consistently outstanding, showcasing creative twists on the bitter Italian classic. This is where serious cocktail enthusiasts come for both the artistry and the ambiance—ideal for impressing a date or celebrating a special occasion in style. The reservation-recommended policy ensures a quality experience, and the rotating decor themes give you an excuse to return multiple times to explore different spaces.

SAINT RESTAURANT BAR & SPEAKEASY on Second Avenue blends the speakeasy concept with a full restaurant and nightclub vibe, offering versatility that few competitors can match. The Espresso Martini here has achieved cult status among East Village night owls—velvety, caffeinated, and dangerously easy to drink more than one. The multi-level space transforms throughout the evening, starting as a relaxed dinner spot before evolving into a cocktail destination and late-night dance floor. It's perfect for groups who can't decide between dinner, drinks, or dancing, since you can experience all three without changing venues.

Sir Henry's, hidden on the first floor of a Midtown building near Times Square, offers a refined escape from the tourist chaos with its 4.8 rating backed by over 1,200 reviews proving its crowd-pleasing appeal. The Whiskey Smash here showcases premium spirits and fresh ingredients muddled to perfection, making it a favorite among bourbon enthusiasts. The space manages to feel both sophisticated and welcoming, attracting a diverse mix of locals, business travelers, and savvy tourists who've done their research. Despite its central location, prices remain reasonable, and the skilled bartenders are adept at handling everything from classic orders to creative custom requests.

Located on the Upper West Side, Prohibition brings 1920s glamour to Columbus Avenue with art deco touches, vintage photographs, and a lively energy that sets it apart from more hushed competitors. The Bee's Knees—a Prohibition-era classic with gin, lemon, and honey—is executed beautifully and embodies the bar's commitment to period-authentic cocktails. With over 1,000 glowing reviews and reasonable prices, it's ideal for groups looking to kick off a night out or theater-goers seeking pre-show drinks in a fun, accessible atmosphere. The bar also serves shareable plates that are surprisingly good, making it easy to settle in for the evening.

Boasting a near-perfect 4.9 rating, Shaken Not Stirred on the Upper East Side delivers James Bond sophistication without the attitude, earning its place as one of NYC's most beloved neighborhood speakeasies. The Classic Martini here is executed flawlessly—ice-cold, perfectly proportioned, and stirred (or shaken) exactly to your preference by bartenders who clearly know their craft. This intimate spot attracts a mix of well-heeled locals and in-the-know visitors seeking expertly crafted cocktails in a relaxed, conversation-friendly environment. The stellar reviews speak to consistent quality and warm hospitality that keeps regulars coming back week after week.

Channeling the elegance of a Victorian parlor, Raines Law Room at The William offers plush velvet seating, ornate decor, and a cocktail program that's taken seriously without being snobbish. The Remember the Maine—a Manhattan variation with cherry liqueur and absinthe—is a sophisticated sipper that perfectly captures the bar's old-world charm. Reservations are essential at this Midtown gem, which caters to a slightly older, more refined crowd including business professionals unwinding after work and couples celebrating special occasions. The presentation is impeccable, with drinks served on silver trays alongside small bites that elevate the entire experience.

Hidden Tiger is the East Village's best-kept secret, a tiny tiger-themed speakeasy accessed through an unmarked door that opened recently and is still flying under the radar. The Tiger's Milk cocktail—a creamy, citrus-forward concoction with pisco and spices—is inventive and dangerously drinkable. With fewer than 100 reviews but a solid 4.3 rating, this intimate spot is perfect for adventurous drinkers who want to discover the next big thing before it hits every Instagram feed in Manhattan. The Asian-inspired cocktail menu is creative and surprisingly affordable, making it an excellent choice for East Village bar crawls.

Step through the stone coffee shop facade into Bathtub Gin, where a sprawling garden-like interior with fairy lights and vintage bathtubs creates an enchanting, almost whimsical atmosphere. The house Bathtub Gin & Tonic, served in a proper copa glass with artisanal gin and house-made tonic, is refreshingly complex and a must-order for first-timers. This Chelsea gem strikes the perfect balance between accessible and special—great for groups celebrating or couples seeking a romantic escape without the stuffiness of some competitors. The rotating seasonal menu means there's always something new to discover, and the spacious layout makes it easier to snag a spot than some of the city's more cramped hidden bars.

Tucked away in the West Village, Do Not Disturb lives up to its name with an intimate, hushed atmosphere that makes you feel like you've stumbled into someone's private salon. The Paper Plane cocktail here is perfectly balanced and showcases the bartenders' dedication to precision and quality ingredients. With its impressive rating and more approachable price point than many competitors, it's ideal for cocktail enthusiasts who want the speakeasy experience without the pretense or the hefty bill. The knowledgeable bartenders are happy to customize drinks based on your preferences, making it a favorite among locals who appreciate personalized service.

Hidden behind a vintage phone booth inside Crif Dogs, PDT (Please Don't Tell) is the granddaddy of NYC speakeasies and remains a bucket-list destination for cocktail lovers worldwide. The Benton's Old-Fashioned, made with bacon-infused bourbon, is legendary for good reason—smoky, rich, and utterly addictive. The dimly lit space features cozy wooden booths perfect for date nights or intimate gatherings with friends, though be prepared for a wait as this iconic spot draws crowds nightly. Pro tip: make a reservation online to skip the line, and don't leave without trying one of their hot dogs from the front before you disappear through that phone booth.